Audio Review: Doctor Who and the Talons of Weng-Chiang

09:05 04 January 2013

Doctor Who and theTalons of Weng-Chiang

Doctor Who and theTalons of Weng-Chiang



THERE can be few Doctor Who stories as beloved as this 1977 tale of giant rats, Chinese Tongs and murderous manikins stalking the streets of Victorian London, so perfectly does it embody all that is remarkable and entertaining about the series.

A mishmash of melodrama concocted by legendary Who scribe Robert Holmes, it draws on influences from the likes of Sax Rohmer’s Fu Manchu stories, Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes series, the Ripper murders, the Phantom of the Opera and any number of Victorian penny fiction tales.

Garbed in a deerstalker and cape instead of his usual hat and scarf, the Fourth Doctor takes futuristic savage Leela to meet her ancestors in 1889 Whitechapel, only to find themselves caught up in a malevolent plot by the hideously deformed 51st century war criminal Magnus Greel, who has been posing as the Chinese god Weng-Chiang in order to reclaim his lost time cabinet.

Allied with theatre owner Henry Gordon Jago and pathologist George Litefoot, they discover Greel has disguised the cyborg assassin known as the Peking Homunculus as a ventriloquist’s dummy called Mr Sin, and that his experiments with the unstable zigma energy have not only bred rats the size of tigers, but threaten to destroy the whole of London...

Christopher Benjamin, who played Jago in the original TV episodes and has since returned to the role for a series of audio adventures, lends his distinctive tones to the reading of the novelisation by Terrance Dicks, the latest in the Target Books range from AudioGo.

The original release of this book came at a time when Dicks was churning out dozens of adaptations of TV scripts with little in the way of expansion or development from the stories as broadcast, and as such it’s quite a lightweight telling of a story which has so much to offer visually as well. It would have been nice to see some of the fleshing out of television stories which characterises other novelisations, rather than a straight-forward retelling of a story easily available on DVD.

That said, you really can’t fault Holmes’ ability to tell a ripping yarn, and his script and dialogue more than makes up for any of Dicks’ shortcomings in novelising what is unquestionably one of the all-time classic Who stories.


More news stories

Yesterday, 16:50

The Royston Repair Cafe returns for a another fix on Sunday with a new free service added to the regular repair of bikes, electrical and other household items.

Yesterday, 12:04

People in Royston were thrilled to see one of the town’s most beloved attractions featured in a national television programme.

Yesterday, 10:29

MPs have reacted to proposals for the South Cambs villages of Bassingbourn, Melbourn, Guilden Morden and Steeple Morden to become part of the North East Herts constituencies – with Heidi Allen telling the Crow it makes ‘no sense’.

Yesterday, 09:30

Police are still at the scene of one of two crashes around Royston this morning.


Most read stories


Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

Read the Royston Crow e-edition E-edition

Newsletter Sign Up