Care proceedings dropped in case of six-month-old boy where fears were raised he had been shaken or smothered

17:05 29 January 2014

Hertfordshire County Council, based at County Hall in Hertford, applied to the High Court to withdraw care proceedings

Hertfordshire County Council, based at County Hall in Hertford, applied to the High Court to withdraw care proceedings

Archant

Care proceedings for a six-month-old boy following concerns he may have been shaken and smothered have been dropped following a High Court judgment.

Hertfordshire County Council (HCC) applied to the High Court to withdraw care proceedings for the child, known only as ‘D’, on the grounds there was insufficient evidence to continue.

The court heard how D had undergone two “life-threatening events” which may have been the result of shaking and smothering, or other abusive behaviour.

Following the incidents, D was made the subject of care proceedings by HCC and removed from his parents and put into foster care.

D’s mother, who cannot be identified for legal reasons, has a history of mental health problems involving depression and suicide attempts. She took an overdose of tablets when D was two days old. But High Court judge Mrs Justice Parker said: “The mother’s mental health has to be seen not in conjunction with, but separately from, the alleged injuries.”

The court heard that evidence from medical experts, including a neurosurgeon and consultant pediatrician with experience in child abuse and trauma cases, was such that, while trauma could not be excluded, it could not be established on the balance of probabilities – the legal requirement – to have occurred.

Mrs Justice Parker said: “It was possible the injuries could have been caused by non-accidental shaking events, but there was no indicator that made the neurosurgeon feel this cause was more likely than any other of the possible causes.

“On the basis of this evidence, the local authority could not satisfy the court that this was inflicted injury and they accept that.”

She added: “The guardian is extremely concerned as to the impact of the mother’s mental health on her ability to provide safe care for D. I understand that concern, but I must approach this matter on a principled basis.

“I have taken fully into account the guardian’s anxieties. I do not consider those anxieties provide the solid ground to decline to accede to the local authority’s application to withdraw.”

The local authority has devised a plan with D’s parents to provide support.

0 comments

Yesterday, 16:03
Hertfordshire police and crime commissioner David Lloyd has said a proposed council tax freeze won't affect recruitment.

Herts’ police and crime commissioner has said a proposed freeze in the force’s council tax precept won’t affect a recruitment drive.

Yesterday, 14:02
A survey has found calls to a debt helpline go up across the area.

The number of people in Stevenage and North Herts turning to debt advice services for help has risen by almost 20 per cent in the last year, new figures show.

Yesterday, 09:25
A10 cycling corridor campaigners Rod Taylor, John Meadows, Tina Filby, Erika Bosman and Susan van de Ven.

A county councillor has spoken of her ‘astonishment’ after plans for a £7.2 million cycling ‘super highway’ connecting Royston and Cambridge were put on hold.

Yesterday, 08:32
Jose Hales, district and parish council and Val Barrett, district and parish council

The organiser of a public exhibition revealing a developer’s plans to build just under 200 homes and a 75 bed care home in Melbourn said he’s pleased with the interest generated by the public.

”North

Most read stories

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Royston Crow e-edition today E-edition